by Rob Lundberg
What is the problem? Well, how can a passage claiming that God moved David to number Israel be not a contradiction to a similar passage in 1 Chronicles 21:1 which claims that it was Satan who caused David to number Israel? Are these passages problematic?
Here are the passages and let’s work this through. I think you will find that there is no problem with the two passages at all.
2 Samuel 24:1: “Now again the anger of the Lord burned against Israel, and it incited David against them to say, “Go, number Israel and Judah.”
1 Chronicles 21:1: “Then Satan stood up against Israel and moved David to number Israel.”
Let me sum up the issue again. One passage (2 Samuel 24:1) it is reported that the anger of the Lord was incited David to number or take a census of the people of Israel and Judah. Verse one affirms that God anger moved David to number the people.
However, according to 1 Chronicles 21:1, it was Satan who moved David to number the people. So the question is who was responsible for prompting David to act? God’s anger or Satan? Are these passages a problem?
Let’s answer a couple of questions that I think will shed some light on their veracity and I believe that we will see that there is no problem and that they do not compromise the inerrancy of the Old Testament.
Question #1: Are these passages a contradiction? The answer to this question is a firm NO. In order for there to be a contradiction, one writer would have to be attributed to both passages. If this were the case, then yes there would be a contradiction.However Jewish tradition tells us that there are two different authors for the books of Samuel and the Chronicles. The Prophet Samuel is credited by Jewish tradition as being the author of 1 & 2 Samuel. Ezra is credited by Jewish tradition as the author of the Books of the Chronicles (1 & 2 Chronicles). None of these writers collaborated with one another, and therefore they cannot be a contradiction.
Question #2: So which these two verses are right? Simply stated, they both are right, or true. Despite the fact that it was Satan who immediately incited David, ultimately it was God who allowed Satan to carry out this provocation. Although it was Satan’s design to destroy David and the people of God, it was God’s purpose to humble David and the people and teach them a valuable spiritual lesson.
This situation is quite similar to the first two chapters of Job in which both God and Satan are involved in the suffering of Job. Similarly, both God and Satan are involved in the crucifixion. Satan’s purpose was to destroy the Son of God (John 13:2; 1 Cor 2:8). God’s purpose was to redeem humankind by the death of His Son (Acts 2:14–39).
This is just one of the many paradoxes of Christianity where the evil one tries to steal the glory from God and declare victory over the souls of men. But God (just those two words are wonderful) comes in and shows how He is ever present and how Satan is only limited in this world.
Postscript: If you would like to have a resource on Bible difficulties, let me refer you to Drs. Norman Geisler and Thomas Howe’s book, The Big Book of Bible Difficulties: Clear and Concise Answers from Genesis to Revelation (formerly titled “When Critics Ask: A Popular Handbook of Bible Difficulties)
Rob is a blogger, writer and public speaker on a mission to equip the believer to think and articulate what they believe and to communicate the message of the gospel to a confused culture in a confused, chaotic, “brave new world.” He is available to come and speak to your church, college club, or group. Find out what people are saying.
If you would like to book Rob for a speaking event, you can do so by emailing him at email@example.com If you have other questions about apologetics or doing apologetics, or if you are looking for apologetics resources, contact our ministry by email.